Jennifer Harris Dault: Missing Two

A year ago today I sat in the ultrasound room holding my breath. I’m not sure why, other than it was one of those moments that—for me—time stopped.


The ultrasound showed an image of a brand new pregnancy—a rice-sized blob with a little flashing dot that showed that there were two hearts beating inside my body. The heart rate was 110—slow for those beginning days—and the doctor looked concerned as he suggested that perhaps our dates were wrong and this was simply a heart just starting to beat.

“I’m cautiously optimistic,” he said.

Nearly two weeks later, my son Benjamin was born—an early miscarriage. He joined his sister Avelyn, born months before after an 11-week gestation period.

I was the mom of two children that I never heard cry.

Tomorrow I will be 21 weeks pregnant with our second son, a yet unnamed squirmy boy nicknamed “Mops” by a friends 4-year-old son. He keeps growing and thriving, and we can’t wait to meet him and welcome him to his new home.

But this pregnancy has not healed me.

The birth of my son will not replace the children not with me.

Each milestone I hit in this pregnancy, I think about the milestones that Avelyn and Benjamin should have reached.

With each new twinge (or lack thereof), I wonder when I’ll hear bad news about Mops. Bad news I can’t help but anticipate every time we see the doctor or midwife.

The world considers me a first-time mom. Each time someone comments on my firstborn or references the first grandchild on my side of the family, I ache.

This is not my first. I have held two others within me, had my water break, felt their birthing time come as my uterus contracted and urged me to push.

I have held them—small as they were—in my hands. I sang them lullabies and journaled throughout their short lives.

Avelyn and Benjamin were—and are—loved deeply, and their lives mattered to their parents.

And yet, there are no words for the birth position Mops holds. Psychology will name him an only child—or the oldest if we have other kids. He will experience life in a way his brother and sister did not.

If all goes well, I will get to hear his cries, see his smiles, lose my sanity to the sleeplessness of the baby stage, feel my heart grow with love.

But our family photos will always be missing two, the invisible playmates our son should have had.


Jennifer Harris Dault is the Associate Pastor at St. Louis Mennonite Fellowship and an advocate for those dealing with infertility and pregnancy and infant loss. She is the editor of “The Modern Magnificat: Women Responding to the Call of God” and blogs infrequently at

4 thoughts on “Jennifer Harris Dault: Missing Two

  1. “But this pregnancy has not healed me.

    The birth of my son will not replace the children not with me.”

    These are such poignant words, Jennifer. One can not replace others–the heart only expands to make room for more–the joy and hope of this child and the pain and absence of Avelyn and Benjamin’s.

    Thanks for being vulnerable and sharing the very real ups and downs, hopes and dreams when the innocence of pregnancy and parenting has already been shattered. I continue to hold you, Allyn and Mops to the Light.

    1. Thanks, Paula. I remember reading after my first loss that the only thing that will bring healing is another pregnancy. I’ve heard that sort of language again and again . . . and I can’t help but wonder where that idea has come from.

  2. As I sit here reading your blog, I’m in tears. I’m not a good writer but it is everything I was thinking. You see, I have 3 missing pieces of my heart. I miscarried in July 2012. I was 6 weeks and again in December 2012 with twins at 14 weeks. I have a beautiful son, now, born april 2014. I love him so much but he can not replace his brothers/sisters that were lost. I love all 4 of my kiddos. It’s been said that time heals all wounds. My heart might heal one day but never will they be forgotten.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s